EFFECT OF OUTSOURCING DECISION ON ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE IN THE MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY [A CASE OF UNGA GROUP LIMITED]
ABSTRACT
Firms have always sought ways to gain a competitive advantage over their competitors; one avenue that firms have pursued to improve their competitive position in this new business environment has been to increase the role of outsourcing in their operations, which has been found to provide a competitive advantage and heightened performance to these firms. However, Firms and Industries under the context of increasing use of outsourcing arrangements, as well as the unfamiliar complexity, are unaware of how to effectively utilize this strategy to improve their performance.
The study therefore purposed to establish the effect of outsourcing decision on organizational performance of Unga Group Limited. It specifically sought to establish the effect of outsourcing for employee competence on organizational performance; find out the effect of outsourcing for cost reduction on organizational performance; examine the effect of outsourcing for innovativeness on organizational performance; and determine the effect of outsourcing to focus on core competencies on organizational performance of Unga Group Limited. This study employed the Resource-Based View theory and employed explanatory survey research design to target the 60 management staff of the four departments of HR, finance, procurement/purchase and marketing. Census method was used to get all the respondents.
Questionnaires were used to collect data. To test the reliability of the instruments Cronbach coefficient Alpha formula was used and the score stood at 0.716 while validity of the instruments was measured by two experts at Nairobi University reviewing the instruments. Data was analyzed using descriptive, correlation and regression analysis then presented in tables. The findings of the study were: employee competence (β=.393, t=5.968, p<0.000), cost reduction (β=.193, t=2.593, p<0.004), innovativeness, (β=.324, t=4.383, p<0.000), and focus on core competencies, (β=.352, t=5.129, p<0.000), had a significant influence on organizational performance at Unga Group Limited, Kenya.
The study therefore recommends: Unga Group Limited should offer better terms of service and proper training to help improve employee competence and reduce costs of outsourcing its HR functions for better performance; they should employ strategic and well thought out outsourcing to further reduce operating and overhead costs for further firm growth; Unga Group Limited should carefully consider the issue of outsourcing to ensure that while outsourcing helps in new innovations, no product quality is compromised and no money is lost; and should clearly ascertain the non-core functions to outsource and further review the potential cost and benefit to be garnered if the non-core functions are outsourced. This study proposes that further research be done in human resource factors influencing outsourcing decision in the textile industry in Kenya.
CHAPTER 1
Firms have always sought ways to gain a competitive advantage over their competitors; however, with the increased movement towards a single globalized economy, this desire is even more prevalent for businesses today. One avenue that firms have pursued to improve their competitive position in this new business environment has been to increase the role of outsourcing in their operations, which has been found to provide a competitive advantage and heightened performance to these firms (Monczka and Trent, 2008; Quinn and Hilmer, 2004).
In the early 80‟s the manufacturing industry was the leading business activity in Kenya, both in terms of size and employment. The industry was employing over 200,000 farming households and about 30% of the labour force in the national manufacturing sector. The sub- sector however started declining in the mid-1980s until the 1990s (Export Processing Zone, 2011). Efforts to spur growth in the manufacturing industry have been considered with outsourcing being one of the strategies.
Dwindling resources and market competitiveness have forced organizations to scrutinize their methods of producing goods and services and make changes in their processes in order to maximize economic returns. To survive and be profitable in current globalization era, organizations have pursued continuous improvement, leaned up production, reengineered business processes, and integrated supply chains (Brannemo, 2006). Over the past decades there is a growing realization of the important contribution of outsourcing strategy on organizational performance (Cousins et al., 2006).
While many firms have followed the pattern of outsourcing some part of their operations to improve their competitiveness, others have not, leading many to ask what factors influence the decision to use outsourcing and how such outsourcing improves organizational performance (Merino and Rodriguez, 2007; Nayak, 2007). Outsourcing is a management strategy by which an organization delegates major, non-core functions to specialized and efficient service providers.
According to preliminary interview with management at manufacturing firms in Nairobi region, these companies are increasingly opting for outsourcing of non-core activities relating
to human resource (HR), information technology (IT) and finance. The companies feel they will be able to focus on their core activity by outsourcing functions like promotions, payroll management, bonus, salary disbursement, provident fund, gratuity, recruitment, flexi-staffing, IT work, new product introduction, security and training to HR consultants. All these are in a bid to provide high service quality, improve on skills and experience and offer innovativeness that would consequently spur performance (Nayak et al., 2007).
In general, outsourcing is considered to be that part of an organization's process, which it sources from outside suppliers, regardless of the type of relation with these suppliers (Mol et al., 2005). As such, every firm engages in outsourcing to some degree, be it manufacturing, customer care, logistics, post sales technical support, finance, auditing, staffing, or design. The choice of what functions to outsource and which to keep in-house is based on the need to develop skills, invest in resources, and stay abreast of evolving technology in any areas kept in-house (Harris, 2008).
In studies examining the impact of outsourcing, there have been several key advantages of outsourcing identified, such as cost savings (Bardhan et al., 2006; Nayak, et al., 2007), reduced capital investment within the firm (Gilley and Rasheed, 2000), improved responsiveness to changes in the business environment and improvement on service delivery (Dess et al., 2005), an increased focus on core competencies (Kotabe and Murray, 2009; Saunders et al., 2007), increased competition among suppliers ensuring higher quality goods and services in the future (Kotabe and Murray, 2009), and a reduced risk of changing technology (Quinn, 2000).
Kenya is one of the top three Business Process outsourcing (BPO) destinations in Africa. In the BPO market, Kenya has a comparative advantage due to the low labour rates for quality services. Although Kenya already has a growing outsourcing sector with over 50 registered companies operational, a boom is expected (Kemibaro, 2011).
Unga Group Limited, founded in the early 1900s, is a flour milling company based in Kenya and is market leader in the manufacturing and provision of superior human nutrition, animal nutrition and animal health products and services within Eastern Africa. In the bid to enhance performance and maintain her competitive advantage the management staff makes some outsourcing decisions.
The Company is headquartered in Nairobi with flour mills in Eldoret, Nakuru and Mombasa. The Company has two business segments, namely Consumer, and Animal Nutrition and Health. The Consumer segment produces products for human consumption. The Animal Nutrition and Health segment produces animal feed and mineral supplement products, and distributes products for animal health. The Company, through its subsidiaries, is engaged in the milling of wheat and maize, and the manufacture of packaging materials and animal nutrition products.
A growing trend in work organization is for firms to outsource many activities that had been previously performed in-house. Outsourcing these activities, it is argued, will free up human and capital resources as well as allow for increased flexibility in the way labour is employed. Although the extent of outsourcing and other approaches to flexibility have been well documented in developed countries, little attempt has been made to evaluate such practices in the Kenyan context and specifically in the manufacturing industry to which Unga Group Limited is a part. The purpose of this study was to review the existing research and to evaluate the effect of outsourcing decision on organizational performance of Unga Group Limited.
Departments
- Accounting Projects [85]
- Accounting And Management Projects [6]
- Accounting Education Projects [1]
- Adult And Primary Education Projects [6]
- Agricultural And Bio-environmental Engineering Technology Projects [8]
- Agricultural Economics And Extension Projects [57]
- Agricultural Engineering Projects [3]
- Agricultural Technology Projects [1]
- Agriculture Projects [104]
- Agriculture Education Projects [3]
- Anatomy Projects [1]
- Architecture Projects [28]
- Banking And Finance Projects [53]
- Basic Medical Sciences Projects [1]
- Biochemistry Projects [25]
- Biological Sciences Projects [46]
- Biology Education Projects [13]
- Botany Projects [3]
- Building Projects [58]
- Business Administration Projects [151]
- Business Studies Projects [76]
- Chemical Engineering Projects [24]
- Chemistry Education Projects [3]
- Civil Engineering Projects [80]
- Community Health Projects [35]
- Computer Education Projects [6]
- Computer Engineering Projects [28]
- Computer Science Projects [138]
- Construction Engineering And Management Projects [1]
- Cooperative Economics Projects [0]
- Cooperative Economics And Management Projects [2]
- Criminology Projects [68]
- Cyber Security Projects [2]
- Data Science Projects [1]
- Economics Projects [107]
- Economics Education Projects [1]
- Education Projects [189]
- Educational Foundation Projects [9]
- Educational Management Projects [44]
- Electrical/electronics Engineering Projects [140]
- English Education Projects [14]
- English Language Projects [6]
- English Language And Literature Projects [18]
- Entrepreneurship Projects [7]
- Environmental Science Projects [79]
- Epidemiology And Community Health Projects [2]
- Estate Management Projects [40]
- Fashion & Design Projects [1]
- Fine Art Projects [1]
- Food And Nutrition Projects [2]
- Food Science And Technology Projects [52]
- Geography Projects [24]
- Geography Education Projects [4]
- Government And Public Administration Projects [1]
- Guidance And Counselling Projects [132]
- Health Education Projects [9]
- Health Information Management Projects [3]
- History And International Studies Projects [3]
- Human Kinetics And Healthy Education Projects [2]
- Human Resources Management Projects [111]
- Industrial Relations And Personnel Management Projects [58]
- Information And Communication Technology Projects [2]
- Institute Of Education Projects [1]
- Insurance And Risk Management Projects [1]
- International Relations Projects [55]
- Islamic Studies Projects [3]
- Law Projects [21]
- Leisure And Tourism Management Projects [2]
- Library And Information Science Projects [85]
- Linguistics Projects [104]
- Marketing Projects [78]
- Mass Communication Projects [188]
- Mathematics Projects [3]
- Mathematics Education Projects [1]
- Mechanical Engineering Projects [86]
- Medical And Health Science Projects [82]
- Medical Laboratory Science Projects [2]
- Medical Radiography Projects [2]
- Medicine And Surgery Projects [2]
- Metallurgical Engineering Projects [2]
- Microbiology Projects [120]
- Minerals And Petroleum Resources Engineering Projects [32]
- Mining Engineering Techology Projects [2]
- Nursing And Nidwiffery Projects [124]
- Office Technology Management Projects [104]
- Parasitology And Entomology Projects [3]
- Petroleum Engineering Projects [3]
- Pharmacy Projects [18]
- Philosophy Projects [111]
- Physics Projects [3]
- Physiology Projects [1]
- Political Science Projects [123]
- Primary Education Projects [5]
- Project Management Projects [1]
- Psychology Projects [61]
- Psychology Education Projects [1]
- Public Administration Projects [123]
- Public Health Projects [100]
- Purchasing And Supply Projects [112]
- Pure And Industrial Chemistry Projects [8]
- Quantity Surveying Projects [59]
- Science Education Projects [4]
- Science Laboratory Technic Projects [108]
- Science Laboratory Technology (stl) Projects [21]
- Secretarial Administration Projects [40]
- Sex Education Projects [2]
- Social Studies Projects [8]
- Sociology Projects [126]
- Statistics Projects [107]
- Surveying And Geoinformatics Projects [4]
- Theology Projects [9]
- Transportation And Management Projects [3]
- Urban & Regional Planning Projects [1]
- Value Engineering Projects [1]
- Vocational Education Projects [1]
- Zoology Projects [1]